When it comes to the many types of cookies, everyone has their favourite - whether it’s a timeless classic or an adventurous new flavour. At Crumbs & Doilies, we’ve baked (and tasted!) more cookies than we can count, and we’ve put together a list of our all-time favourite cookie flavours, past and present, that you simply have to try.
From gooey New York-style classics to creative flavour combinations, this ranking celebrates the best cookie flavours we’ve ever made. Whether you’re inspired to bake them yourself or want to enjoy cookie delivery straight from our bakery, we’ve got you covered.
Our Favourite Types of Cookies: Ranked
At Crumbs & Doilies, we’re all about thick, gooey New York-style cookies that deliver bold flavours and indulgent textures in every bite. From classic crowd-pleasers to unique creations you won’t find anywhere else, we’ve ranked our top picks to help you discover the best cookie flavours.
Chocolate Chip Cookies
No cookie list would be complete without the timeless chocolate chip cookie. At Crumbs & Doilies, it’s our all-time bestseller, and for good reason. Thick, golden, and packed with gooey chocolate chips, this classic is the ultimate comfort treat.
What makes ours so special? It’s a flawless combination - soft, buttery dough with a satisfying chew and pockets of melted chocolate in every mouthful. A favourite for any occasion, this cookie proves that simplicity done right is unbeatable.
Get your hands on our chocolate chip cookies or bake them yourself with our chocolate chip cookie kit!
Caramel Cornflake Cookies
Imagine a rich, double chocolate cookie made with intense black cocoa for a bold, chocolatey flavour that’s as striking as it is delicious. But the real surprise? Hidden inside each cookie is a gooey caramel cornflake centre - salty, sweet, and irresistibly chewy.
For the ultimate crunch, we coat these cookies with even more crunchy, malty cornflakes. The result? A cookie that’s perfectly balanced with a touch of bitterness from the cocoa, the sweetness of caramel, and the satisfying crunch of cornflakes. It’s everything you could want in a treat and more.
Want to Try These Cookies?
Cookies and Cream Cookies
This cookie is a nostalgic nod to everyone’s favourite childhood treat—cookies and cream. Packed with crushed cookies and creamy white chocolate chunks, it delivers a perfect balance of crunch and sweetness. We love this cookie for its playful twist on a classic dessert, with each bite offering a mix of smooth chocolate and crumbly cookie pieces.
Try baking them at home with our recipe and enjoy a nostalgic treat. Or, order our Cookies and Cream Cookies for home delivery!
Birthday Cake Cookies
Who doesn’t love a cookie that feels like a party in every bite? Our Birthday Cake Cookies are packed with creamy white chocolate chunks and colourful rainbow sprinkles, making them as fun to eat as they are to look at. The combination of sweetness from the white chocolate and the nostalgic flavour of sprinkles gives this cookie a playful charm. It’s one of our favourites because it’s impossible not to smile while eating it!
Want To Make Your Own?
Red Velvet Cookies
Rich, vibrant, and indulgent Red Velvet Cookies are a true standout. They perfectly capture the flavour of a classic red velvet cake in cookie form, with a hint of cocoa and a soft, chewy texture. What makes these cookies a favourite is their luxurious combination of flavours, finished with just the right amount of cream cheese sweetness.
Recreate these beauties with our recipe and enjoy their signature red velvet goodness at home!
Biscoff Cookies
Biscoff Cookies are a Crumbs & Doilies classic for good reason. Each cookie features a gooey centre of spiced biscuit spread, melty white chocolate, and crunchy Biscoff crumbs, creating a perfect balance of textures and flavours. The combination of caramelised warmth and rich, creamy filling makes these cookies an all-time favourite - comforting, indulgent, and undeniably delicious.
Want to make your own? Check out our Biscoff Cookie Baking Kit!
White Chocolate and Pretzel Cookies
Salty meets sweet in our White Chocolate and Pretzel Cookies—a combination that’s impossible to resist. These cookies are packed with creamy white chocolate, caramelised white chocolate for extra depth of flavour, and perfectly salty pretzels for a delightful crunch.
The balance of salty and sweet is what makes this cookie so special. Each bite is a satisfying blend of smooth, buttery chocolate and crisp, salty pretzel pieces, creating the perfect treat for any occasion.
Watch our step by step recipe to whip up a batch in no time!
Double Chocolate Chip Cookies
When one dose of chocolate just isn’t enough, the Double Chocolate Chip Cookie steps in. Made with a rich cocoa base and packed with chunks of milk and dark chocolate, this cookie is pure indulgence for chocolate lovers. Its fudgy centre and slightly crisp edges make it a standout among our favourite types of cookies. We love how it satisfies even the strongest chocolate cravings.
Cereal Milk Cookies
Inspired by the childhood joy of slurping the leftover milk after a bowl of cereal, our Cereal Milk Cookies capture that unique flavour in cookie form. With a buttery base and a hint of sweet, malty goodness, these cookies are as fun as they are delicious. They’re crunchy on the outside, chewy on the inside, and always a hit with anyone who tries them.
Order your Cereal Milk Cookies now or get creative and bake them at home with our step-by-step recipe!
Kinder Bueno Cookies
If you’re a fan of the iconic Kinder Bueno bar, this cookie is your dream come true. Packed with creamy hazelnut filling and chunks of chocolate, Kinder Bueno Cookies bring together all the flavours you love in one indulgent bite. What makes them special is the gooey hazelnut centre that oozes out with every bite, perfectly balancing sweetness and nuttiness.
Get inspired with our STUFFED Kinder Bueno Cookie recipe!
Raspberry White Chocolate Cookies
Raspberry White Chocolate Cookies offer a perfect mix of fruity and sweet flavours. The tart raspberries balance beautifully with the rich, toasty notes of caramelised white chocolate chunks, creating a cookie that feels fresh yet indulgent. The vibrant raspberries add colour and flavour, making this one of our most-loved creations.
Black Forest New York Cookies
Our Black Forest New York Cookies take inspiration from the classic Black Forest gâteau, but with a Crumbs & Doilies twist. Packed with gooey chocolate chips, two types of cherries for a fruity burst, and rolled in cacao nibs for a satisfying crunch, these cookies deliver layers of flavour and texture. The richness of chocolate pairs perfectly with the tangy sweetness of the cherries, making this an indulgent cookie for true chocolate lovers.
Get baking with our Black Forest New York Cookie recipe and enjoy this decadent treat at home!
Oatmeal & Raisin Cookies
Oatmeal & Raisin Cookies are a classic for a reason, and ours take this traditional favourite to the next level. The oats add a wonderful chewy texture, while the gooey, squishy raisins bring a natural sweetness to every bite.A touch of cinnamon brings the flavours together, adding a cosy warmth to the cookie’s taste. These cookies are so good they almost feel like a treat you could justify for breakfast - almost!
Try baking them yourself with our Oatmeal & Raisin Cookie recipe and enjoy this timeless favourite!
Matcha and Macadamia Cookies
Matcha and Macadamia Cookies bring together the earthy notes of Japanese green tea and the rich, buttery crunch of macadamia nuts. These cookies stand out with their vibrant green colour, crisp edges, and gooey centres. The subtle matcha flavour pairs perfectly with the creamy, nutty macadamias, creating a treat that’s as visually striking as it is delicious.
Try baking Matcha and Macadamia Cookies with our recipe and enjoy a truly unique cookie flavour!
Nutella Filled Cookies
Nutella Filled Cookies deliver a light, chocolatey flavour with a rich, gooey Nutella centre that takes them to the next level. The addition of roasted hazelnuts adds a subtle crunch and enhances the cookie's nutty flavour throughout. The hazelnuts are roasted to bring out their full aroma, perfectly complementing the smooth Nutella filling.
Bake your own Nutella Filled Cookies with our recipe and enjoy this chocolate and hazelnut favourite!
Lemon Meringue Cookie
Made with fresh lemon zest for a zesty kick and dotted with crunchy baked meringue pieces, these cookies are full of flavour and texture. The bright lemony notes are balanced by the sweet, airy meringue, creating a cookie that feels light yet satisfying. It’s a refreshing option for anyone craving something a little different.
Bake a batch of Lemon Meringue Cookies with our recipe and enjoy our citrus-infused favourite!
What Makes Our Cookie Flavours Special?
At Crumbs & Doilies, our cookies are crafted with quality, creativity, and care to make every bite memorable. Here’s what sets our cookie flavours apart:
1. Exceptional Ingredients
We carefully select the finest ingredients, from rich black cocoa and caramelised white chocolate to freshly zested lemons. Each element is chosen to enhance flavour and create cookies that are truly irresistible.
2. Unique Flavour Combinations
Our cookies stand out for their bold and imaginative flavour pairings. Whether it’s Matcha & Macadamia, Lemon Meringue, or Black Forest, we’re always experimenting to bring fresh ideas to life.
3. Perfect Texture in Every Cookie
From crisp edges to gooey centres, our cookies are designed for the ideal texture. Using techniques like chilling dough and incorporating roasted nuts or premium chocolate ensures the perfect balance in every bite.
4. Handmade with Care
Each cookie is handmade with attention to detail. Whether it’s a gooey filling or a crunchy topping, every element is carefully crafted to create a standout treat.
5. Something for Every Taste
With a wide variety of flavours, from nostalgic classics to inventive creations, there’s a cookie for everyone. Whether you crave the comfort of Chocolate Chip or the boldness of Matcha, we’ve got you covered.
At Crumbs & Doilies, every cookie is a celebration of flavour and creativity. Explore our collection, try baking with our recipes, or have cookies delivered fresh to your door!